Is it better to grow cuttings in water or straight into soil? I've got a strong opinion now
I've been propping plants for about 3 years now, and I always thought water was the safest way to go. You can see the roots, change the water weekly, watch for rot. But last spring I decided to run a little test with my pothos and coleus cuttings. I took 10 cuttings from the same mother plant and put 5 in water, 5 directly into moist potting mix. The water ones rooted fast, no doubt, but when I transplanted them to soil after about 4 weeks, nearly half of them went into shock and dropped leaves. The soil ones took a little longer to show growth, maybe 6 weeks, but once they took off they were way more robust and never had that transplant struggle. Has anyone else tried both methods and found a clear winner for certain types of plants? I'm curious if it's just my specific setup or if this holds true for others.