Serious question, has anyone else tried to settle a book club argument with a dramatic reading?

Our group's debate over whether a character in 'The Silent Patient' was truly remorseful got so heated that I decided to perform the key monologue in a full Shakespearean accent, which accidentally convinced three people the book was a historical drama set in Victorian England, so what's the most bizarre way a debate has derailed your club?

3 comments

3 Comments

the_ryan1mo agoMost Upvoted

Oh man, that's amazing. I actually used to think book clubs were all polite chats over wine, but then ours spent twenty minutes yelling about whether a sandwich in a story was a metaphor. Someone brought in actual bread to prove a point, and now I'm convinced any debate can turn weird fast. Your Shakespeare bit is way more creative than our carb-based argument, though.

karen_perry381mo ago

Honestly I used to picture book clubs as super chill too, just talking about themes over snacks. But after hearing about your Shakespeare bit and reading @the_ryan's story about the bread, my whole view is flipped. Our group once got stuck for a full hour because two people could not agree on the color of a house described in one paragraph. It started normal and then someone pulled up paint swatches online. It proves there's no limit to how silly these talks can get.

-1

lopez.karen21d ago

Bringing up paint swatches is next level dedication, I love it. What nobody's talking about is how these fights actually make you remember the book way better than a chill chat ever would. I still picture that bread argument from the other thread every time I look at a baguette, but your house color debate would stick with me even harder. Did anyone actually change their mind about the color or did you just agree to disagree?