Our book club's vote for next month's pick completely fell apart last night

We were supposed to pick between three books, but two members brought extra suggestions and derailed the whole meeting. It started with Sarah from Tacoma saying, 'I just can't get into historical fiction right now,' and then it spiraled. We spent 45 minutes just listing titles without any structure. I finally suggested we all vote by email in the next 24 hours to pick from the original three. Has your group ever had a simple vote turn into a mess like that?

3 comments

3 Comments

oliver214d ago

Sarah's new ideas sound better than your list.

robinson.wren14d ago

Sarah's ideas might sound better, but I read that the original list had more detail.

daniel5933d ago

Look, that email vote idea just shuts down good conversation. Sarah had a real point about not wanting historical fiction, and those new suggestions could have been great. Sometimes the original list just isn't working for everyone, and a messy talk is how you find a book people actually care about. Cutting it off with a rushed vote means you might end up with a pick half the club isn't excited to read. The best choices often come from that kind of open, unstructured debate, even if it feels chaotic at the time.

-1