Loading…

Overheard a guy at the coffee shop say his smart speaker heard him snoring and ordered a CPAP machine on its own | Ethical Tech Dilemmas - Opinions Matter

tyler6•5mo ago

Overheard a guy at the coffee shop say his smart speaker heard him snoring and ordered a CPAP machine on its own

He was dead serious, said Alexa picked up the snoring pattern during a nap and added a $300 device to his cart. I asked if he actually bought it, and he just shrugged and said "it showed up two days later." Has anyone else had their tech go rogue like that?

3 comments

3 Comments

simons285mo ago

Used to roll my eyes at people saying their devices were listening in on them. This story actually has me rethinking that stance because it makes a weird kind of sense if the AI is programmed to notice health stuff. Still creepy that a machine can just order expensive medical gear without you touching a button though.

hannahs455mo ago

Yeah but @simons28, how many times have we heard stories like this and it turns out the person was misremembering or the device wasn't even on. People swear their phones are listening but nobody can ever prove it. This one article says a machine ordered something but really, it could just be a coincidence or bad reporting. I bet there's a ton of context missing here. Not saying it's impossible, just that I need more than one viral story to believe my toaster is diagnosing me.

kai_butler833mo ago

Oh come on, this is the kind of story that just feeds the paranoia machine. I've seen so many of these "my tech is alive" posts and it's always the same thing - someone's kid ordered a toy by accident or they left their card info saved on a random site. The Alexa isn't diagnosing you, it's just a glorified search bar with a microphone. If my speaker could actually figure out my snoring patterns and order medical gear, it would have caught onto my late-night pizza habit and just bought me a whole Dominos by now. The guy probably fell asleep shopping after having a few drinks and forgot about it. Plus, even if the recording picked up snoring, there's like a million steps between "makes a sound" and "authorizes a $300 purchase" that require human thumbs. Let's not give these boxes more credit than they deserve.