Loading…
22
Just realized my attempt at ethical investing led me to fund a plastic bottle plant
I put money into what I thought was a clean water ETF, feeling all virtuous about supporting sustainability. After bragging to friends, I glanced at the holdings and saw a huge chunk goes to a company that manufactures single-use plastic bottles. Couldn't help but laugh at the irony of my 'green' move backing the exact opposite. Now I'm double-checking every fund's actual assets before investing another dime.
3 comments
Log in to join the discussion
Log In3 Comments
aliceflores7mo ago
ESG funds often greenwash. Considered direct impact investments?
4
jamie_moore7mo ago
What gets missed in this debate is the sheer difficulty of measuring real impact, even with direct investments. In my experience, many impact projects suffer from self reporting and a lack of standardized metrics, which isn't that different from ESG fund vagueness. Your mileage may vary, but I've found that without third party verification, direct investments can become just feel good stories without substantive change. Take this with a grain of salt, but the focus should be on outcomes, not just intentions, whether it's a fund or a direct project. The real issue is that capital allocation needs to be tied to auditable results, which is a hurdle for both models. So while direct investing avoids some fund manager bias, it introduces its own set of challenges in proving it's not just another form of greenwashing.
-1