I was sure those 'wipe on poly' kits were just a lazy shortcut, but my friend in Denver proved me wrong with a 100 year old oak dresser.

4 comments

4 Comments

Yeah, I was the same way, always thought you needed to brush on multiple coats for a real finish. Tried a wipe-on poly on an old pine table last year because I was short on time, and it came out shockingly well. The key is just taking your time with more thin coats, and it doesn't leave any brush marks. That dresser probably looks amazing with a hand-rubbed look now.

sarah5316d ago

Honestly wipe-on poly can be fine for a quick fix, but it never seems to build the same tough layer for me. Maybe it's just me but on something that gets real use, like a kitchen table, I still go back to a brushed finish. It takes more skill to avoid marks, but the extra protection feels worth the hassle. That hand-rubbed look is nice, but I'd worry about how it holds up over years.

miamitchell5d ago

Pine is softwood, so that wipe-on test doesn't prove much for hard use.

amy_adams135d ago

Forget the thin coats and hand-rubbed look. Matthewkim got lucky with a pine table, but try that on a real work surface and watch it fail. Wipe-on poly is just a watered-down finish that can't take a real beating. You need the full build and hardness of a brushed coat for anything that will actually be used, not just sit in a corner. That old oak dresser is a show piece, not proof the shortcut works for real furniture.